Disproving a statement with a counterexample
One valid counterexample is enough.
- State that the variable represents an integer when proving integer properties.
- Use algebra to cover every permitted value. Factor out the divisor or 2 when helpful.
- One counterexample disproves a universal statement; several examples do not prove it.
Example 1
Disprove: “
For , the result is 6, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Example 2
Disprove: “
For , the result is 12, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Your turn
Question 1 One valid counterexample is enough. This has factors 4 and 5, both greater than 1.
Disprove: “
Check answer
For , the result is 20, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Question 2 One valid counterexample is enough. This has factors 5 and 6, both greater than 1.
Disprove: “
Check answer
For , the result is 30, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Question 3 One valid counterexample is enough. This has factors 6 and 7, both greater than 1.
Disprove: “
Check answer
For , the result is 42, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Question 4 One valid counterexample is enough. This has factors 7 and 8, both greater than 1.
Disprove: “
Check answer
For , the result is 56, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Question 5 One valid counterexample is enough. This has factors 8 and 9, both greater than 1.
Disprove: “
Check answer
For , the result is 72, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Disprove: “
For , the result is 20, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Disprove: “
For , the result is 30, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Disprove: “
For , the result is 42, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Disprove: “
For , the result is 56, which is not prime. The statement is false.
Disprove: “
For , the result is 72, which is not prime. The statement is false.